Legend has it that O’Rourke mortgaged his mother’s house to print 2,000 copies. However, a warehouse flood destroyed 75% of the print run before distribution. The remaining 500 copies were sold out of the trunk of a ’78 Chevy Impala at punk rock shows and zine fairs.
The book captures a specific American moment: the death of the Rust Belt, the rise of MTV, and the loneliness of the overnight shift. It is often compared to the works of Harvey Pekar ( American Splendor ) but with a heavier dose of physical violence and Irish-Catholic guilt. As of 2025, the average selling price for a "Very Fine" condition copy of the Fat Keily Book has exceeded $1,200. For a signed copy? One recently listed on a niche auction site had a reserve of $4,500. Fat Keily Book
Keep your eyes on the dollar bins. Somewhere, under a pile of old Archie digests, that fat spine might just be waiting for you. Have you ever seen a copy of the Fat Keily Book in the wild? Share your story in the comments below. Legend has it that O’Rourke mortgaged his mother’s