A: Even the free episodes are copyrighted material. Torrenting the free episodes is legal gray area (since they are freely distributed), but pointless, as you can just download them legally from the RSS feed.
If you love history, pay the man for his work. Your next favorite episode depends on it. Dan Carlin Hardcore History Torrent
FAQ: Quick Answers for the Torrent Curious Q: Is there a complete Hardcore History torrent that includes Supernova in the East? A: No. Modern torrents are consistently outdated because Carlin releases episodes so infrequently. The moment a torrent is updated, a new episode comes out a year later. A: Even the free episodes are copyrighted material
It is no surprise, then, that the search term is incredibly popular. With episodes often running 3 to 6 hours long (and the Supernova in the East series clocking in at over 25 hours), listeners want to consume everything at once without paying a dime. Your next favorite episode depends on it
When you download a of his back catalog, you aren't stealing from a faceless media conglomerate (like stealing a Marvel movie from Disney). You are taking money directly out of the pocket of an independent researcher who spends six months writing a single episode.